The Curious Case of Derek Sherrod

Derek Sherrod

I would like to start by saying this: Derek Sherrod is a world class athlete and I am a media hack.  Actually, check that, I aspire to one day be a media hack.  I can’t stand when members of the media that did not compete at the highest level compare themselves to professional athletes (see Skip Bayless and his 1.7 ppg for Northwest Classen HS).  It’s a way of establishing credibility that really doesn’t exist.  With that said I’m going to do the exact same thing to share my unique perspective on the case of Derek Sherrod (LOLZ).


When examining the Packer offense, the one thing that can be pointed to now as a major weakness is the offensive line.  You could say running back, but you’d most likely be incorrect.  Between Eddie Lacy, Jonathan Franklin, and DuJuan Harris there is going to be an above average NFL RB coming out of that crew, if not more than one.  Tailback is a young man’s game and the Packers have 3 of the most promising RB prospects under the age of 25.  What they’re missing, and what would really make this team go would be a stud left tackle.  That way Bulaga could play right tackle, where he has the potential to be an all pro (I love Bulaga, but he will never be one of the best 3 or 4 LT in football) and Aaron Rodgers would still be protected.


The thing is, the Packers should have one. They drafted one in the 1st round! They drafted a 6’6” 305 pound SEC athlete. Sherrod allowed only one sack as a senior and was credited with 32 pancake blocks in the toughest conference in the country.  If you hired a police sketch artist to come in and draw you the perfect left tackle, he would look a lot like Derek Sherrod.  Don’t get me wrong, Derek Sherrod struggled a little as a rookie.  He was played at guard (terrible idea) to compete with TJ Lang for a starting spot on the line and never quite got acclimated to the NFL game in the NFL’s lockout shortened offseason.  I attended the opening game against the Saints that season and to my dismay Sherrod walked out of the tunnel in shorts and T shirt as a healthy scratch, benched in favor or 2nd year man Marshall Newhouse.


Sherrod would make enough progress throughout the season to be activated on game days (although that could have had to do with the injury to Chad Clifton) and saw limited time until he was thrust into the only regular season loss of 2011 against Kansas City.  In that game Sherrod suffered one of the worst injuries I can remember seeing as a Packers fan.  Sherrod had a compound fracture of the tibia and fibula.  This means that both of the bones in his lower leg were broken to the point that they both exited the skin.  Sherrod’s leg was put in an air cast and he was required to stay in Kansas City for emergency surgery.  It’s now been over 18 calendar months since that surgery and Sherrod still isn’t being cleared to practice.  This frustrates members of the media and fan base.


Between my senior year of high school and freshman year of college in June of 2006 I suffered the exact same injury.  I shattered my lower leg, incurring a compound fracture (outside the skin) of both the tibia and fibula.  I spent the next 6 weeks immobile on the couch. 3 months in physical therapy and was on crutches for 6 months total.  Rehab was slow and painful and I developed plantar fasciitis under my left foot.

I played golf in college and my rehab goal was to be ready to play in the spring to be ready for the fall season of my sophomore year. I was unable to swing a club until January of 2007. I continued my rehabilitation but even during fall season I was told I would limp noticeably towards the end and after 18 hole rounds.  In high school I could dunk smaller objects that I could palm (like a volleyball or women’s basketball) and I haven’t been able to do any more than graze the rim at any time since that injury.  There’s still a part on the bottom of my foot that has no feeling from nerve damage (think the black foot in Mr. Deeds, I could step on anything and it wouldn’t hurt).


My point is this: Derek Sherrod is a world class athlete with one of the best training staffs in the world helping him along the way.  What concerns me is that if I was around 170 pounds in college and all I was trying to do after a year and a half was hit a little white ball around a field less than a hundred times can I really ask Derek Sherrod to carry 310 pounds and block Julius Peppers after 18 months?  I’m not sure I can.  Mike Flanagan is an excellent example of a player that was given the time to heal after a catastrophic injury and became a really good player for the Packers, and I would ask for the same kind of patience with Derek Sherrod.

The kind of player that Sherrod can be is exactly what this team needs, and I would hate to see the Packers have to use a 1st round pick investment on a player at the same position as Sherrod just 3 years after they thought they had their guy.  Reports are coming in that McCarthy thinks he’s close to being able to practice in pads.  Derek Sherrod isn’t a bust. He isn’t soft. He just got hurt really, really bad. Give him time.


Ross Uglem is a writer at You can follow Ross on twitter at RossUglem


  • CD Angeli

    I’ll be honest: I really don’t have much hope Sherrod is ever going to be able to contribute. That’s not his fault, nor anyone’s fault, but it is a reality. Now, if he does manage to make the most incredible comeback in Packer history, I’ll cheer him until my lungs fail. Just don’t have a lot of hope in it happening.

    Now, as a result, the Packers still have this gaping hole at tackle that had Sherrod’s name written all over it. While we can all congratulate Ted Thompson’s success in the mid- and even late-rounds, its further evidence that you just can’t miss in the first and not have it come back to bite you. Again, not TT’s fault at all, just a reality that we’re having auditions again at tackle with late-round guys and free agents.

    Well-loved. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 5 Thumb down 1

    • Ross Uglem

      Gee CD, thanks for comin’ in and darkening up everybody’s morning.

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 1

      • c.d. angeli

        It’s what I do best. 😉 If you need some rainbows and unicorns, go find Rehor.

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 2

        • Actually CD I’m known more for puppy dogs and rainbows

          Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 1

    • I strongly adhere to injury forgiveness, a “totally” shattered lower leg takes 1. Time, and that is a genetic issue(see AP vs.RG), 2. Correctly supervised physical therapy, (NFL trainers? Ok there) and 3. The mental toughness and commitment to return and justify the status of being a number ONE pick. I think Mr. Sherrod meets all of the above and return year 3 as a, what 26yr. old dynamic left tackle! Comeback player of the year, and really could well be considered as a “Rookie”, he will justify number 1 pick and become a perennial All-Pro! Book it!

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • Many have pointed to Sherrod’s failure at OG as an indictment to his abilities to play LT. First off Lang is a very good player so to beat him required a tremendous effort and I doubt that Sherrod in his first year had the strength to pull it off. Second, tackles don’t always switch easily to guards. So because Sherrod didn’t blow away everyone his first TC wasn’t an indication that he was a bust or bad player. Take away that perception and the thought that he has the best medical staff around him to get him back up to full strength……he may still be salvageable.
    I’m sorry you had to go through that pain and rehab and had to do some of that myself w/ two broken elbows. I hope that medical rehab for us is different than for a professional football player. Next year is when I think Derek will make a difference and look forward to seeing him crushing the DE/DT that try and sack Rodgers.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 1

  • Greg

    What proof do you have Ross that Bryan Bulaga won’t be a solid LT? Let him play the position in a game and prove his worth there before casting that opinion. I know this is an article on Derrick Sherrod, but that little nugget stood out.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  • Mark Richardson

    Most fans are frustrated by the lack of information regarding Sherrod. If the Packers came out and said Sherrod would not play for two years then I think most would understand. But if he can’t play soon I would expect him to be released.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 1

  • Ross Uglem

    CD I think Rehors on vacation. Mackid, that’s a very strong possibility. Mark I’m of the opinion that their trigger isn’t going to be quite as quick. Greg, nowhere did I say Bulaga can’t be solid. I think he will be in fact but I have my very serious doubts that he’ll ever be truly elite at LT and he could be an all pro RT. Thanks for the feedback guys I really appreciate it.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 2

  • Let’s hope he can come back. It’s not his fault but maybe it’s time to retire. Let’s hope he can heal up.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • c.d. angeli

    Now, the Sherrod at guard experiment Mau have factored in, bit not on the way you might guess. McCarthy and Co. Have long believed in interchangeable linemen. Sherrod isn’t a jack of all trades…he’s a stud tackle. I think he lost a lot of valuable work flailing away at guard when he should have been taking reps at his future position.

    Now…does that mean he was hurt because he didn’t get his conditioning and training at tackle? Probably not. But suddenly MM and Co. Have now assigned players their spot and are working them exclusively there. Maybe a lesson learned the hard way.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  • John Zoul

    Some interesting perceptions concerning Sherrod. I did not fully appreciate the severity of his injury and think that maybe it would make sense to just put him on IR now and let him rehab for another year. It appears the same might be necessary for JC Tretter and Jerel Worthy. It would appear that Datko is finally healthy and Bakhtiari looks to be an NFL player, so we already have some young depth at tackle and let’s hope the O-Line will be improved from last year. With D. Sherrod, I hope he is eventually able to comeback all the way and play starting tackle for us, it seems apparent that will not be the case in the 2013 season.

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0