The Packers’ Defense Against Veteran Quarterbacks

All the attention has been given to the Green Bay Packers’ offense recently and rightfully so. The offense is the reason for the struggles of the team and it’s so different then what it has been in the past. We all know the problems there though. Aaron Rodgers hasn’t been accurate, the receivers can’t get open — and when they do often drop the ball — the coaches cannot scheme players open, they’re not getting enough running attempts and the whole offensive line is on the injury report. Yikes, that’s a lot. With that being said, it would be a good time to look at what the Green Bay defense is doing and just how good it really is.

The Packers have played really good defense for three consecutive weeks. However, about the only thing different from the past was when they shut down Adrian Peterson. Dom Capers and his defense has always had the numbers of Matthew Stafford and Jay Cutler in the past. They also lose some credit for the Detroit game when they gave up seven points on the most crucial drive of the game. If the defense makes a stop there the Packers very likely win the game. Playing well until it really matters has been a theme recently under Capers. The 2014 NFC Championship game would be the most glaring example.

The Packers are a top 10 scoring defense this season, ranking eighth in the NFL at 19.5 points per game. They’re in the top half of the NFL in Football Outsiders DVOA at 13th. They have some great talent at all levels on the defense. Mike Daniels and Datone Jones have been dominant recently up front (Jones coming off the edge at times as well), Clay Matthews has been amazing against the run, and the secondary is extremely talented. Ha Ha Clinton-Dix has had a very solid season other than the Carolina disaster, and playing Casey Heyward on the inside with Sam Shields and Damarious Randall outside is a huge step up from Hayward outside and Micah Hyde inside. Hyde should not really see the field a lot anymore with Quentin Rollins showing up well blitzing and in coverage . So, there is a lot to work with here.

The problem tends to be veteran quarterbacks and quarterbacks who can run. Dom Capers’ schemes have been around forever and veteran quarterbacks can pick them up pretty easily. This happened in the second half of the Bears game when Adam Gase went to all those bubble screens to counter Capers’ blitzing. Capers never found an answer. Phillip Rivers was constantly making adjustments at the line in the San Diego game and nothing was ever changed. It just always seems like in a big spot a Capers blitz rarely gets home.

I wanted to test the theory out about the defense not performing against established veteran quarterbacks. By my calculations, the Packers have had 19 of those games since 2013, and I went back and combined the stats for those 19 games. In those 19 games the Packers faced Russell Wilson three times, Colin Kaepernick twice, Tony Romo twice, Matt Ryan twice, Cam Newton twice, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, Andy Dalton, Joe Flacco, Eli Manning and Ben Roethlisberger. Those quarterbacks have gone a combined to go 409/644 (63.5 percent completion percentage) for 5,299 yards (279 yards per game) with 37 touchdowns against 16 interceptions and a 99.7 passer rating. The Packers have also allowed an average of 28 points per game in these matchups.

Is this good enough? Probably not if your aspiration is to win the Super Bowl because these are the kind of quarterbacks you will have to beat in the playoffs. When the Packers won the Super Bowl in 2010 the opposing quarterbacks did not have stats like that in the postseason. Obviously, these quarterbacks are good and everybody’s numbers will be worse against them than the bottom feeder quarterbacks, but the Packers have rarely had a good game against any of them. The 2014 NFC Championship game is the outlier and if you take that out it probably looks worse. You can cut a quarter of the interceptions off right away. As mentioned before, they collapsed when it mattered most that game anyways taking away from the overall performance.

Mike McCarthy and the Packers will always look to the overall numbers regarding the defense and try to make you believe things will be different against these quarterbacks until we get there and it isn’t. It’s what keeps Capers in his job every year. This defense seems to fall right in line with poor games against Manning, Rivers and Newton but solid in all others. With the offense looking the way it has for almost two months, the Packers better hope their defense isn’t fools gold like it has been in the past.



Matt Bove is a writer at You can follow him on twitter at @RayRobert9.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 thoughts on “The Packers’ Defense Against Veteran Quarterbacks

  1. It is fool’s gold if we look at quarterbacks that constantly connect with their receivers. But there is a slight improvement. Special teams is much improved. The offense is going backwards fast. Even fill-in quarterbacks have better stats than Rodgers, Kirk Cousins, Orweiler, etc. So how are we going to beat Detroit where Stafford can connect long, and with Megatron, no less? But changes in staff personnel are not going to happen in Green Bay, and I’m referring to coaching. With the high salaries the coaching staff makes. They’ll hold on to their jobs like hungry dogs to their bones.

  2. This is an excellent article. Couldn’t agree with you more. Capers defense regularly makes good players look like HOFers. Although they have been playing well lately, how many times am I gonna hear ” career high” or “best game this season” from the announcers when they are discussing our opponents during the game. Im not calling for major changes just think we should try and capitalize with Rodgers before we go through 2 HOF qbs and only get 2 SBs.

  3. So….good QBs do better against the Packers than average QBs?

    1. Hard to believe, I know.
      Damn that Capers.
      He didn’t score enough points on Thursday. Winning the Super Bowl every season isn’t happening. He should be fired.

      1. All we have to do is hire a defensive coordinator that does better against good QBs than average QBs?

      2. Playoffs seven seasons in a row. Only the Pats can match that. And we’re picking from the bottom of the draft year after year. I’m well happy with the way the team have played in recent years. Remember when they couldn’t dream of playing in the post season? It’s nice to win the Superbowl but thirty odd other teams want the same thing.

Comments are closed.